Difference Between

Difference Between Sister Chromatids and Homologous Chromosomes

Nex Virox Team
Written byNex Virox Team
Editorial Team
Varshal Nirbhavane
Senior SEO & Organic Growth Professional · 5+ years
18 min read
Quick answer

The main difference between Sister Chromatids and Homologous Chromosomes is that sister chromatids are identical copies joined at a centromere, while homologous chromosomes are matched pairs from each parent. Sister Chromatids is one half of a duplicated chromosome, while Homologous Chromosomes is a pair of similar but non-identical chromosomes.

Key takeaways

  • Core distinction: Sister chromatids are identical copies joined at a centromere, while homologous chromosomes are similar but non-identical pairs.
  • Origin and pairing: Sister chromatids arise from DNA replication of one chromosome, whereas homologous chromosomes come one from each parent.
  • Genetic content: Sister chromatids carry identical alleles, but homologous chromosomes carry different alleles for the same genes.
  • Cell division role: Sister chromatids separate during mitosis and meiosis II, while homologous chromosomes separate during meiosis I.
  • Common mistake: Confusing sister chromatids with homologous chromosomes causes errors in predicting gamete genetic variation outcomes.

Difference Between Sister Chromatids and Homologous Chromosomes: Comparison Table

AspectSister ChromatidsHomologous Chromosomes
DefinitionTwo identical copies of a single chromosome linked at the centromere.Two similar chromosomes inherited from each parent, one maternal and one paternal.
PurposeEnsure equal distribution of genetic material to daughter cells during division.Carry corresponding genes and enable genetic recombination during meiosis.
Core MechanismSeparate during anaphase of mitosis and anaphase II of meiosis.Pair and exchange segments during prophase I of meiosis.
OriginFormed by DNA replication during the S phase of interphase.Inherited as separate chromosomes from each biological parent at conception.
Genetic ContentCarry identical DNA sequences with the same alleles at each locus.Carry the same genes but often different alleles at corresponding loci.
Structural PairingTwo chromatids joined at a single centromere forming one chromosome.Two separate chromosomes that pair transiently during meiosis only.
Centromere CountShare one centromere between the two chromatids.Each homologous chromosome has its own distinct centromere.
OccurrencePresent after DNA replication until cell division completes.Present throughout the cell cycle in diploid somatic cells.
Cell Division RoleSeparate in mitosis to produce genetically identical daughter cells.Segregate independently during meiosis to produce genetic variety.
RecombinationDo not undergo crossing over with each other.Exchange genetic material via crossing over during prophase I.
Number in Humans92 chromatids present in a diploid cell after DNA replication.23 pairs of homologous chromosomes exist in human somatic cells.
ShapeTwo parallel strands connected at the centromere forming an X shape.Each chromosome has its own independent shape and size.
Allele RelationshipAlways carry identical alleles at every genetic locus.Carry alleles that may be identical or different at each locus.
Separation TimingSeparate during anaphase of mitosis and anaphase II of meiosis.Separate during anaphase I of meiosis.
Genetic DiversityProduce no genetic diversity when they separate.Generate diversity through independent assortment and crossing over.
Matching GenesMatch every gene perfectly with no sequence variation.Match gene order but may differ in specific allele versions.
Pairing StabilityRemain attached until anaphase, then separate completely.Pair transiently during meiosis and then separate permanently.
DNA ReplicationResult directly from one round of DNA replication.Exist as separate molecules before and after replication.
Cell Type PresenceAppear in dividing cells during S, G2, and M phases.Exist in all diploid cells regardless of division state.
Chromosome NumberCount as one chromosome despite having two chromatids.Count as two distinct chromosomes in a homologous pair.
Function in MitosisSeparate equally to ensure daughter cells receive identical DNA.Do not pair or interact during mitotic cell division.
Function in MeiosisSeparate in meiosis II after homologous chromosomes separate first.Pair and recombine in meiosis I before separating.
Error ConsequencesNondisjunction causes aneuploidy in daughter cells.Mis-pairing can lead to chromosomal abnormalities and disorders.
Visual AppearanceAppear as a single X-shaped structure under a microscope.Appear as separate rod-shaped structures of similar size.
Genetic IdentityGenetically identical copies produced by replication.Genetically similar but not identical due to different parental origins.
Replication TimingCreated simultaneously during a single S phase.Each replicates independently during the same S phase.
Crossing OverNever participate in crossing over events.Frequently exchange segments during prophase I of meiosis.
Typical UsersStudied in mitosis and meiosis cell division contexts.Studied in genetics, inheritance, and evolutionary biology contexts.
Key LimitationCannot generate genetic variation due to identical sequences.Pairing only occurs during meiosis, not in mitosis.
Best-Fit ScenarioBest for understanding equal DNA distribution in cell division.Best for studying inheritance patterns and genetic variation.

What Is Sister Chromatids?

Sister chromatids are two identical copies of a single replicated chromosome, joined at a centromere. They exist after DNA replication to ensure each new cell receives an exact genetic copy during cell division.

Definition of Sister Chromatids

Sister chromatids are genetically identical DNA molecules produced by chromosome replication, held together by cohesin proteins at the centromere until anaphase. They separate during mitosis and meiosis II, guaranteeing faithful transmission of genetic information to daughter cells.

Key Characteristics of Sister Chromatids

CharacteristicWhat It Means in Practice
Genetically identicalEach carries the same allele sequence, so separation yields two identical daughter cells.
Centromere linkageCohesin proteins bind them at a constricted region until anaphase triggers separation.
Post-replication originThey appear only after S phase, when DNA polymerase completes synthesis of both strands.
Pair count per chromosomeOne replicated chromosome contains exactly two sister chromatids, never more or fewer.
Separation timingThey split in anaphase of mitosis and anaphase II of meiosis, not in meiosis I.
Homologous pairing roleDuring meiosis, they remain attached while homologous chromosomes align alongside them.
Cohesin degradation triggerSeparase enzyme cleaves cohesin, allowing spindle microtubules to pull chromatids apart.
DNA repair functionThey serve as templates for homologous recombination repair of double-strand breaks.
Replication fidelity markerMismatch repair uses the sister chromatid to correct errors introduced during synthesis.
Visual appearanceUnder a microscope, they look like an X shape with two arms joined at the middle.

Common Examples of Sister Chromatids

  • Human chromosome 1 – the largest human chromosome, its two sister chromatids span roughly 249 million base pairs each.
  • Drosophila polytene chromosomes – undergo repeated replication, producing thousands of sister chromatids aligned in parallel bundles.
  • Yeast chromosome III – a model organism where sister chromatid cohesion is studied using temperature-sensitive cohesin mutants.
  • Human chromosome 21 – trisomy arises when sister chromatids fail to separate during meiosis, causing Down syndrome.
  • Mouse chromosome 2 – used in live-cell imaging to track sister chromatid separation in embryonic stem cells.
  • Arabidopsis chromosome 5 – plant model where sister chromatid cohesion defects cause developmental stunting and sterility.
  • Xenopus egg extracts – cell-free system where sister chromatid formation is induced by adding sperm nuclei to extract.
  • Human chromosome X – in females, one sister chromatid pair inactivates randomly, forming a Barr body.
  • Chicken DT40 cells – used for gene targeting experiments that test sister chromatid exchange rates.
  • Human chromosome 22 – smallest autosome, whose sister chromatids are used to study telomere shortening across divisions.

Advantages and Limitations of Sister Chromatids

AdvantagesLimitations
Guarantee identical genetic copies in daughter cells, preventing variation from replication errors.Cohesin failure causes aneuploidy, which is the leading cause of miscarriage and birth defects.
Provide a repair template for double-strand breaks, preserving genome integrity after DNA damage.Their physical attachment delays chromosome segregation, creating a bottleneck during rapid cell cycles.
Enable accurate chromosome counting during metaphase, aiding karyotype analysis in clinical diagnostics.They cannot recombine with each other, so they offer no source of new genetic diversity.
Allow spindle microtubules to attach from opposite poles, ensuring balanced tension before anaphase.Premature separation in meiosis I produces gametes with extra or missing chromosomes, causing disorders.
Facilitate sister chromatid exchange, a process that helps repair replication-associated DNA lesions.Their identical nature makes it impossible for cells to distinguish which chromatid carries an original mutation.
Support faithful chromosome segregation over hundreds of cell divisions in stem cell populations.Cohesin proteins require ATP hydrolysis for loading, consuming cellular energy during every cell cycle.
Enable error-free repair of single-strand gaps left by stalled replication forks during S phase.Their tight cohesion can mask DNA damage, delaying checkpoint activation until after segregation begins.
Provide a natural internal control for measuring DNA replication fidelity in laboratory assays.They are transient structures, existing only from S phase to anaphase, limiting their study window.
Allow sister chromatid cohesion to guide homologous chromosome pairing during meiosis I prophase.Their separation requires precise proteolytic control, and any misregulation triggers cell cycle arrest or apoptosis.
Support the spindle assembly checkpoint, which halts division until all chromatids attach correctly.They cannot correct errors once separated, making anaphase a point of no return for genetic fidelity.

What Is Homologous Chromosomes?

Homologous chromosomes are paired chromosomes, one inherited from each parent, that carry matching genes at corresponding positions. They exist to enable genetic variation through recombination during meiosis. This pairing ensures offspring inherit a balanced set of genetic instructions while maintaining species chromosome number.

Definition of Homologous Chromosomes

Homologous chromosomes are two chromosomes within a diploid cell that share the same gene sequence, length, and centromere position, though they may carry different alleles. One member originates from the maternal parent and the other from the paternal parent, forming a functional pair during cell division.

Key Characteristics of Homologous Chromosomes

CharacteristicWhat It Means in Practice
Maternal and paternal originOne chromosome comes from the egg, one from the sperm, forming a true pair.
Matching gene lociGenes for the same trait sit at identical positions on both chromosomes.
Allelic variationDifferent versions of a gene, called alleles, can exist on each member.
Equal chromosome lengthBoth members have similar physical size, aiding proper alignment during meiosis.
Identical centromere positionThe constriction point sits at the same spot, enabling stable pairing.
Same banding patternStaining reveals identical structural patterns, confirming their homology.
Pair during prophase IThey physically align via synapsis to exchange genetic material.
Segregate in anaphase IMembers separate to opposite poles, halving chromosome number in gametes.
Diploid number requirementPresent only in diploid cells; haploid gametes carry just one member.
Independent assortmentPairs align randomly, producing diverse gamete combinations in offspring.

Common Examples of Homologous Chromosomes

  • Human Chromosome 1 – the largest human pair, carrying over 2,000 genes for diverse traits.
  • Human X and Y Chromosomes – a sex-determining pair that shares small pseudoautosomal regions for pairing.
  • Human Chromosome 21 – a small acrocentric pair; trisomy of this pair causes Down syndrome.
  • Fruit Fly Chromosome 2 – a model pair used extensively in classical genetic inheritance studies.
  • Mouse Chromosome 7 – a pair homologous to parts of human chromosome 11, useful in disease research.
  • Corn Chromosome 9 – a pair known for visible knob markers that track recombination events.
  • Pea Plant Chromosome 4 – carries the seed shape gene, central to Mendel's inheritance experiments.
  • Dog Chromosome 1 – the largest canine pair, linked to several breed-specific hereditary conditions.
  • Baker's Yeast Chromosome III – a small pair that controls mating type switching in this fungus.
  • Zebrafish Chromosome 5 – a pair with conserved synteny to human chromosomes, aiding vertebrate studies.

Advantages and Limitations of Homologous Chromosomes

AdvantagesLimitations
Enables genetic recombination during meiosis, creating novel allele combinations in offspring.Misalignment during pairing can cause unequal crossover, leading to harmful gene duplications or deletions.
Provides a backup copy of essential genes, masking deleterious recessive mutations in heterozygotes.Recessive disorders persist silently across generations, evading natural selection until two carriers mate.
Allows independent assortment, generating vast genetic diversity within a species population.Independent assortment produces unpredictable trait combinations, complicating selective breeding outcomes.
Facilitates DNA repair using the homologous member as a template during double-strand break repair.Repair machinery can mistakenly use a non-homologous chromosome, causing chromosomal translocations and cancer.
Supports proper chromosome segregation, reducing the risk of aneuploidy in daughter cells.Nondisjunction still occurs, producing gametes with extra or missing chromosomes and conditions like trisomy.
Enables dosage compensation mechanisms, balancing gene expression between sexes with different sex chromosomes.X-inactivation randomly silences one homolog, creating mosaic tissues with variable gene expression patterns.
Provides a platform for gene conversion, allowing one allele to copy onto the other member.Gene conversion can spread harmful alleles through a population faster than natural selection can remove them.
Allows comparative mapping between species, identifying conserved genes and evolutionary relationships.Structural differences between homologs, like inversions, can reduce fertility in hybrid offspring.
Supports imprinting regulation, where certain genes express only from the maternal or paternal copy.Imprinting errors cause severe developmental disorders, including Prader-Willi and Angelman syndromes.
Permits recombination hotspots to shuffle alleles efficiently, accelerating adaptive evolution.Hotspots can become self-destructive, causing biased gene conversion that erodes genetic variation over time.

Similarities Between Sister Chromatids and Homologous Chromosomes

Shared AspectHow Sister Chromatids and Homologous Chromosomes Are Alike
DNA CompositionSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both consist of tightly packed DNA molecules wrapped around histone proteins.
Primary FunctionSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both serve to carry and transmit genetic information during cell division.
Cell Division RoleSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both participate actively in mitosis and meiosis to segregate genetic material.
Chromosome CategorySister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both belong to the broader category of chromosome structures within eukaryotic nuclei.
Replication OriginSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both arise from DNA replication processes that duplicate genetic material.
Protein AssociationSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both associate with cohesin and condensin proteins for structural organization.
Microscopic VisibilitySister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both become visible under light microscopes during condensed cell division stages.
Genetic Material CarrierSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both carry genes that determine heritable traits across generations.
Structural UnitSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both form from chromatin fibers that fold into compact organized structures.
Centromere PresenceSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both contain centromeres that serve as attachment points for spindle fibers.
Spindle AttachmentSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both connect to microtubules from opposite poles during cell division alignment.
Segregation MechanismSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both undergo separation processes guided by the mitotic or meiotic spindle apparatus.
Genetic InformationSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both store hereditary instructions encoded in their DNA base sequences.
Nuclear LocationSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both reside within the nucleus of eukaryotic cells during interphase.
Condensation CycleSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both condense during prophase and decondense after division completes.
Copy NumberSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both exist as paired structures following DNA replication in preparation for division.
Evolutionary OriginSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both evolved from ancient DNA packaging systems in early eukaryotic organisms.
Repair ParticipationSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both serve as templates for DNA damage repair through recombination pathways.
Recombination SubstrateSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both provide physical platforms for genetic crossover during meiosis.
Mendelian InheritanceSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both follow Mendelian segregation patterns that govern trait transmission.
Karyotype ComponentSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both appear in standard karyotype analyses used for genetic screening.
Staining ResponseSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both react similarly to Giemsa and other chromosome-specific laboratory stains.
Structural IntegritySister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both depend on proper protein scaffolding to maintain their structural integrity.
Cell Cycle TimingSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both form during S phase and function through M phase of the cell cycle.
Error SusceptibilitySister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both risk nondisjunction errors that cause aneuploidy in daughter cells.
Clinical RelevanceSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both factor into genetic disorder diagnostics and prenatal screening tests.
Research UtilitySister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both serve as essential subjects in cytogenetic and molecular biology research.
Copy FidelitySister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both require high-fidelity duplication to prevent mutations from propagating.
Organism DistributionSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both occur across all sexually reproducing eukaryotic species.
Functional OutcomeSister chromatids and homologous chromosomes both ultimately ensure each daughter cell receives the correct genetic complement.

Sister Chromatids or Homologous Chromosomes: Which Should You Choose?

The correct answer depends entirely on what stage of cell division you are studying. Sister chromatids are genetically identical copies joined at one centromere, while homologous chromosomes are a matched pair from each parent. For mitosis and DNA replication questions, choose sister chromatids; for meiosis and genetic variation questions, choose homologous chromosomes.

When to Use Sister Chromatids

Choose Sister Chromatids when tracking identical genetic copies during mitosis or when a chromosome has just replicated. Use them for questions about splitting at the centromere during anaphase, counting chromatids after S-phase, or explaining how daughter cells receive exact DNA copies. They are also correct when comparing identical alleles on a single replicated chromosome.

When to Use Homologous Chromosomes

Choose Homologous Chromosomes when comparing maternal and paternal gene copies or during meiosis I pairing and crossing over. Use them for questions about independent assortment, tetrad formation, or why siblings inherit different allele combinations. They are also correct when discussing non-identical alleles (A versus a) at the same gene locus on matched chromosomes.

Common Misconceptions About Sister Chromatids and Homologous Chromosomes

Common MythThe Reality
Sister chromatids and homologous chromosomes are the same structure seen at different times.Sister chromatids are identical copies joined at a centromere, while homologous chromosomes are separate maternal and paternal chromosome pairs.
Homologous chromosomes are always identical in their DNA sequence.Homologous chromosomes carry the same genes but different alleles, so their DNA sequences differ between the maternal and paternal copies.
Sister chromatids exist in every cell throughout the entire cell cycle.Sister chromatids form only during S phase and exist through G2 and mitosis, disappearing after anaphase separates them.
Homologous chromosomes pair up and exchange DNA during every cell division.Homologous chromosomes synapse and cross over only during meiosis prophase I, not during mitosis or meiosis II.
A single chromosome contains only one chromatid at all times.A replicated chromosome contains two sister chromatids, so a single chromosome can hold either one or two chromatids depending on cell cycle stage.
Sister chromatids carry different alleles for the same gene.Sister chromatids are exact DNA copies produced by replication, so they carry identical alleles unless a mutation occurred during copying.
Homologous chromosomes are exact copies of each other produced by DNA replication.Homologous chromosomes are inherited one from each parent, not produced by replication, and they differ in allele composition.
Crossing over happens between sister chromatids to create genetic diversity.Crossing over occurs between non-sister chromatids of homologous chromosomes, and sister chromatid exchange does not create new allele combinations.
Humans have 46 sister chromatids in every normal body cell.Humans have 46 chromosomes, which become 92 sister chromatids only after replication during S phase of the cell cycle.
Homologous chromosomes separate during anaphase of mitosis.During mitosis anaphase, sister chromatids separate, while homologous chromosomes separate only during anaphase I of meiosis.
Sister chromatids pair with each other during meiosis to form tetrads.Tetrads form when homologous chromosomes pair during meiosis I, and each tetrad contains four sister chromatids total from both homologs.
Homologous chromosomes are found only in reproductive cells like gametes.Homologous chromosomes exist in all diploid somatic cells, while gametes contain only one copy of each homologous pair.
Each sister chromatid comes from a different parent.Both sister chromatids come from the same parental chromosome copy, so they share the same maternal or paternal origin.
Homologous chromosomes are identical in length and centromere position always.Homologous chromosomes usually match in length and centromere position, but structural variations like inversions can alter these features.
Chromatids and chromosomes are completely different structures with no relationship.A chromatid is one half of a replicated chromosome, so chromatids are chromosome components rather than separate structures.
Homologous chromosomes replicate during meiosis prophase I just before pairing.Homologous chromosomes replicate during interphase before meiosis begins, so they arrive at prophase I already containing two sister chromatids each.
Sister chromatids separate during meiosis I along with homologous chromosomes.Sister chromatids stay together during meiosis I and separate only during meiosis II anaphase, while homologs separate in meiosis I.
Sex chromosomes X and Y are homologous chromosomes with identical genes.X and Y chromosomes are homologous only in small pseudoautosomal regions, and they carry mostly different genes in males.
Homologous chromosomes are produced when a chromosome splits down the middle.Homologous chromosomes are inherited as separate copies from each parent, and chromosome splitting produces sister chromatids instead.
Every chromatid in a cell is genetically unique from all other chromatids.Sister chromatids are genetically identical to each other, so a replicated chromosome contributes two identical chromatids to the cell.
Crossing over between homologous chromosomes occurs during mitosis to repair damage.Mitosis uses sister chromatid exchange for DNA repair, while homologous recombination with crossing over is restricted to meiosis prophase I.
Homologous chromosomes align randomly at the metaphase plate during mitosis.During mitosis, individual chromosomes align independently, and homologous chromosomes do not pair or align together at the metaphase plate.
Sister chromatids are inherited one from the mother and one from the father.Sister chromatids are copies of a single parental chromosome, so both chromatids trace back to the same mother or same father.
Homologous chromosomes contain the same alleles because they carry the same genes.Homologous chromosomes carry the same gene loci but can hold different alleles, such as one copy with brown eye allele and one with blue.
A tetrad contains two homologous chromosomes and two sister chromatids total.A tetrad contains two homologous chromosomes with four sister chromatids total, which is why it is also called a bivalent.
Homologous chromosomes are attached at the centromere like sister chromatids are.Homologous chromosomes are not physically attached; only sister chromatids are joined at the centromere until anaphase separates them.
Chromosome number doubles when sister chromatids form during S phase.Chromosome number stays the same during S phase, but DNA content doubles because each chromosome now has two sister chromatids.
Homologous chromosomes separate during meiosis II just like sister chromatids do.During meiosis II, sister chromatids separate, while homologous chromosomes already separated during meiosis I anaphase.
Sister chromatids recombine with each other to shuffle genetic material in offspring.Sister chromatids are identical, so their recombination produces no new allele combinations, and only homologous chromosome crossing over creates diversity.
Cells with homologous chromosomes are haploid because they have paired copies.Cells with homologous chromosome pairs are diploid, and haploid cells like gametes contain only one chromosome from each homologous pair.

Conclusion

Difference Between Sister Chromatids and Homologous Chromosomes comes down to origin and role. Sister chromatids are identical copies joined at the centromere, ensuring accurate division. Homologous chromosomes are matched pairs from each parent, enabling genetic variation. Pick sister chromatids for mitosis; pick homologs for meiosis.

FAQs on Difference Between Sister Chromatids and Homologous Chromosomes

What is the main difference between sister chromatids and homologous chromosomes?
Sister chromatids are identical copies of a single chromosome connected at the centromere, while homologous chromosomes are two separate chromosomes, one from each parent, that carry matching genes.
Are sister chromatids genetically identical to each other?
Yes, sister chromatids are genetically identical because they result from DNA replication of one original chromosome, ensuring each daughter cell receives the same genetic information.
Which pair separates during mitosis, sister chromatids or homologous chromosomes?
Sister chromatids separate during mitosis, while homologous chromosomes remain paired only during meiosis, making chromatid separation essential for normal cell division in body cells.
What is the cost of a mistake in sister chromatid separation?
A mistake in sister chromatid separation causes aneuploidy, where daughter cells receive incorrect chromosome numbers, leading to conditions like Down syndrome or cancer cell formation.
What is the risk of recombination between non-sister chromatids of homologous chromosomes?
The risk is beneficial genetic variation, because crossing over between non-sister chromatids exchanges DNA segments, creating new allele combinations without causing harmful mutations.
Are homologous chromosomes compatible for pairing in every cell type?
No, homologous chromosomes pair only during meiosis in germ cells, not in somatic cells, because pairing requires the synaptonemal complex that forms exclusively during prophase I.
What is a common beginner mistake when identifying sister chromatids?
A common mistake is calling the two copies of a duplicated chromosome homologous pairs, when they are actually sister chromatids joined by a single centromere.
Can sister chromatids and homologous chromosomes be used interchangeably in genetic diagrams?
No, they cannot be used interchangeably because sister chromatids represent one chromosome, while homologous chromosomes represent two distinct chromosomes, changing the count and meaning of the diagram.
How do sister chromatids function in a real-world DNA repair scenario?
In real-world DNA repair, sister chromatids serve as the preferred template for homologous recombination repair, providing an identical sequence to accurately fix double-strand breaks without error.
Can I switch the terms sister chromatids and homologous chromosomes when describing meiosis?
No, you cannot switch the terms because sister chromatids separate in anaphase II, while homologous chromosomes separate in anaphase I, so swapping them misrepresents the meiotic stages.