Difference Between

Difference Between Persona 5 and Royal

Nex Virox Team
Written byNex Virox Team
Editorial Team
Varshal Nirbhavane
Senior SEO & Organic Growth Professional · 5+ years
20 min read
Quick answer

The main difference between Persona 5 and Royal is that Royal adds a third semester, new characters, and expanded gameplay mechanics. Persona 5 is the original 2016 JRPG with 80 hours of story, while Royal is the 2019 enhanced re-release with 100+ hours, new social links, and a revised ending.

Key takeaways

  • Core distinction: Persona 5 Royal is an expanded re-release adding a third semester, two new party members, and a new story arc.
  • Gameplay mechanics: Royal introduces Showtime attacks, a grappling hook for stealth, and expanded social activities like darts and billiards.
  • Quality-of-life upgrades: Royal adds baton pass rank-ups, a new Will Seed collectible system, and a more forgiving difficulty curve than the original.
  • Best-fit use case: Choose Royal for first-time players wanting the definitive experience; choose the original only for budget or nostalgia reasons.
  • Common decision mistake: Assuming Royal is just a cosmetic remaster—it changes boss fights, adds a new true ending, and alters the final act significantly.

Difference Between Persona 5 and Royal: Comparison Table

AspectPersona 5Royal
DefinitionBase 2016 JRPG about rebellious Phantom Thieves changing corrupt hearts.Expanded 2019 re-release adding new story arc, characters, and gameplay systems.
Core StoryFollows Joker's journey through seven palaces across one school year.Adds a third semester, new palace, and true ending after original finale.
New CharactersFeatures original cast including Morgana, Ryuji, Ann, and Yusuke only.Introduces Kasumi Yoshizawa, Takuto Maruki, and new confidant Jose.
Third SemesterGame concludes after defeating final boss in February with no extension.Adds playable January through March with new palace and final boss.
New PalaceContains seven main palaces plus Mementos depths for story progression.Adds a new eighth palace in the third semester with unique mechanics.
Gameplay CombatUses standard turn-based combat with Baton Pass and technical damage.Adds Showtime attacks, new enemy types, and enhanced technical system.
Grappling HookLacks any grappling or vertical exploration mechanics in palaces.Adds grappling hook for reaching hidden areas and treasure in palaces.
Will SeedsContains no collectible Will Seeds within any palace locations.Adds three Will Seeds per palace granting exclusive accessories.
New ConfidantsFeatures twenty confidants including party members and social links.Adds two new confidants plus ranks for existing characters reaching 10.
Thieves DenLacks any gallery or replay system for cutscenes and artwork.Adds Thieves Den with trophies, music player, and character viewer.
Velvet RoomOffers standard fusion and persona strengthening through Igor.Adds Jose's flower collecting and new fusion alarms for accidents.
Fusion AlarmsNo fusion alarm mechanic exists during persona fusion process.Adds fusion alarms triggered randomly granting boosted stats or skills.
New PersonasContains base roster of 200+ personas from series history.Adds new personas including Kasumi's unique and third-tier evolutions.
Third AwakeningsParty members stop at second persona evolution during story.Adds third-tier personas unlocked via confidant rank 10 in third semester.
Showtime AttacksNo paired special attacks exist between party members.Adds paired Showtime attacks triggered by conditions with unique animations.
Mementos DepthMementos has 50 floors with basic stamp collection only.Adds Jose's stamps for buffs and new Mementos requests.
Daytime ActivitiesOffers limited activities like batting cages, part-time jobs, and study.Adds darts for baton pass upgrades and billiards for technical damage.
New MinigamesContains crossword puzzles, fishing, and video games at cafe.Adds darts, billiards, and new Tycoon card game with party members.
Difficulty OptionsOffers five difficulty settings from Safety to Merciless.Adds new Challenge difficulty and adjusts Merciless damage multipliers.
New Game PlusAllows carrying compendium, social stats, and equipment over.Adds new third semester content accessible only in New Game Plus.
DLC ContentIncludes launch DLC with costume packs and bonus personas.Includes all original DLC plus new Kasumi and challenge battle packs.
Visual PresentationUses stylized UI with red and black color scheme throughout.Refines UI with gold accents and improved menu transitions.
Audio TracksFeatures original soundtrack by Shoji Meguro with 40+ tracks.Adds new tracks including "Colors Flying High" and new battle themes.
PerformanceRuns at 30 FPS on PS3 and PS4 with loading screens.Improves loading times and maintains 60 FPS on PS5 via backwards compatibility.
Platform AvailabilityReleased on PS3 and PS4 in 2017.Released on PS4 in 2020, later ported to Switch, PC, and Xbox.
Playtime LengthMain story takes roughly 80-100 hours to complete fully.Adds 20-30 hours for new content totaling 100-130 hours.
Price PointTypically sold at standard retail price or discounted to $20.Often priced higher at $60, with Royal being definitive edition.
Critical ReceptionReceived strong reviews with Metacritic score around 93.Scored slightly higher at 95 on Metacritic with universal acclaim.
Best ForPlayers wanting original story without extended content or budget gaming.New players seeking complete experience with all improvements and content.

What Is Persona 5?

Persona 5 is a 2016 Japanese role-playing game by Atlus. You play as a Tokyo high school student leading a double life as a Phantom Thief. The game exists to blend dungeon-crawling combat with high school social simulation and turn-based strategy.

Definition of Persona 5

Persona 5 is a turn-based JRPG where you explore cognitive dungeons called Palaces. You recruit personas, forge social links, and manage daily time. Its core loop alternates between real-world activities and supernatural heists to change corrupt hearts.

Key Characteristics of Persona 5

CharacteristicWhat It Means in Practice
Turn-based combatYou exploit enemy weaknesses to earn extra turns and trigger stylish all-out attacks.
Social linksBuilding Confidants unlocks new abilities, fusion bonuses, and deeper character stories.
Time managementEach day has day and evening slots; choosing activities permanently affects your progress.
Persona fusionYou combine captured personas to create stronger ones with new skills and resistances.
Palace explorationEach main villain has a themed dungeon with stealth mechanics, traps, and treasure routes.
Mementos dungeonThis procedurally generated subway lets you grind levels and complete side-quest requests.
Phantom Thief outfitYour party wears rebellious costumes that reflect their inner personas and fighting styles.
Negotiation systemYou talk with demons during battle to recruit them, demand items, or earn money.
Confidant abilitiesRanking up friends grants practical perks like lockpicking, item crafting, or bonus experience.
Original soundtrackAcid-jazz tracks like "Last Surprise" play during encounters and boss fights.

Common Examples of Persona 5

  • Kamoshida's Palace - A corrupted gym teacher's castle serves as the first tutorial dungeon teaching stealth and weakness exploits.
  • Ann Takamaki - A party member whose Persona, Carmen, specializes in fire magic and enemy charm effects.
  • Ryuji Sakamoto - Your best friend uses physical skills and lightning attacks with his Persona, Captain Kidd.
  • Mementos - An endless subway dungeon where you complete requests from random civilians and grind for experience.
  • Fusion Alarm - A bonus state that occasionally triggers after battle, enabling stronger fusion results and skill mutations.
  • All-Out Attack - A cinematic team finisher that triggers when you knock down every enemy in a battle.
  • Joker's Masks - The protagonist switches between multiple personas mid-battle, giving him unmatched elemental coverage.
  • Shujin Academy - The high school setting where you attend classes, take exams, and build daily relationships.
  • Velvet Room - A blue prison where Igor and Caroline help you fuse personas and manage your compendium.
  • Phantom Thieves' calling card - A signed notice you send to villains before a heist, which changes their Palace's final layout.

Advantages and Limitations of Persona 5

AdvantagesLimitations
Stylish presentation with a unique anime art direction and memorable UI animations.Its 100-hour campaign demands a massive time investment that casual players may not afford.
Deep tactical combat rewards planning around enemy weaknesses and status ailments.Dungeon stealth sections can feel repetitive, especially during long palace crawls.
Engaging social simulation makes every character feel meaningful and well-developed.The linear first few hours restrict your freedom with heavy tutorial railroading.
Persona fusion offers hundreds of combinations for creative party building.Some confidant abilities arrive too late to meaningfully affect your playthrough.
Excellent soundtrack and voice acting create a fully immersive atmosphere.Randomized Mementos floors lack the handcrafted design of main story palaces.
Strong anti-corruption themes resonate with modern social issues and injustice.Difficulty spikes at certain boss fights can frustrate players who skip grinding.
Multiple difficulty options and new game plus modes extend replay value.Daytime activities are permanently missable if you choose poorly, causing stress.
Confidant rewards directly improve combat, exploration, and crafting efficiency.The original release lacks quality-of-life features added in later versions.
Mementos requests provide a steady stream of side content and lore.Some side quests require specific social stats that take many in-game days to raise.
Phantom Thief outfits and persona designs are iconic and visually distinct.The game's mature themes may not suit younger or sensitive players.

What Is Royal?

Royal is the enhanced re-release of Persona 5, adding a third school semester, two new characters, and a grappling hook for stealth movement. It exists to expand the original narrative with deeper character arcs and refined gameplay mechanics, offering veterans a fresh experience.

Definition of Royal

Royal is a 2019 role-playing video game developed by Atlus, serving as an expanded definitive edition of Persona 5. It introduces a new playable character, Kasumi Yoshizawa, a new antagonist, Takuto Maruki, and a redesigned Tokyo setting with additional story content and quality-of-life improvements.

Key Characteristics of Royal

CharacteristicWhat It Means in Practice
Third SemesterAdds a new story arc from January to February, focusing on Maruki's reality-altering powers and true happiness themes.
Kasumi YoshizawaNew party member with a unique DLC costume and a gymnastics-based Persona, joining the Phantom Thieves after the third palace.
Grappling HookEnables vertical exploration in palaces, allowing players to reach hidden treasure chests and new safe rooms.
Showtime AttacksPair-specific combo moves between two party members, triggered under specific conditions, dealing massive damage.
Batting Cage ExtrasAdds a new batting mini-game with a score attack mode, plus a dartboard minigame for social stat boosts.
Will SeedsThree collectible items per palace, each granting a unique accessory and restoring SP when all are gathered.
New ConfidantsAdds Kasumi (Faith), Maruki (Councillor), and Goro Akechi's expanded ranks, altering the ending requirements.
Improved CombatAdds technical damage bonuses, new enemy types, and a baton pass upgrade that increases damage after a status ailment.
Thieves DenA museum-like gallery featuring trophies, music, and cutscene viewers, rewarding exploration with unlockable content.
Xbox & PC ReleaseRoyal was ported to Windows, Xbox One, and Switch in 2022, expanding beyond the original PlayStation 4 exclusivity.

Common Examples of Royal

  • Persona 5 Royal - The definitive PS4 and modern platform release, adding the third semester and Kasumi's full story arc.
  • Persona 5 Royal (Switch) - A 2022 port enabling handheld play, with all DLC included and cross-save via Nintendo Online.
  • Persona 5 Royal (Xbox Game Pass) - Available on Xbox One and Series X|S, making the game accessible to a broader subscription audience.
  • Persona 5 Royal (PC) - A Steam release with adjustable graphics settings, supporting 4K resolution and 60 FPS.
  • Persona 5 Royal (PS5) - Backward compatible on Sony's next-gen console, offering improved load times and stable performance.
  • Kasumi Yoshizawa DLC - A free update adding her as a playable character in the original Persona 5, but fully integrated in Royal.
  • Maruki's Councillor Confidant - A new social link that must reach rank 9 before November to unlock the true ending.
  • Akechi's Third Awakening - A new Persona evolution for Goro, available only if his confidant reaches rank 8 by November.
  • Joker's Showtime with Kasumi - A unique combo attack featuring a dance-like sequence, exclusive to Royal's pairing system.
  • Thieves Den Gallery - A menu-based museum with 100+ trophies, including a fishing minigame and a darts challenge.

Advantages and Limitations of Royal

AdvantagesLimitations
Adds 20+ hours of new story content, including a fully voiced third semester with a unique villain.Requires a 70+ hour base playthrough before the new content becomes accessible, delaying the payoff.
Introduces Kasumi Yoshizawa, a well-written character with a tragic backstory and a distinct combat style.Kasumi is absent from the first two palaces, making her integration feel uneven for a main party member.
Improves quality-of-life features like fast-forwarding dialogue and skipping battle animations.Some original Persona 5 players find the new content intrusive, especially the forced Maruki scenes.
Adds a grappling hook that makes palace exploration more vertical and rewarding with hidden treasures.The grappling hook is only usable in palaces, not in the real world or Mementos, limiting its utility.
Includes all original DLC costumes and Personas from Persona 5, saving players extra purchases.New DLC costumes for Kasumi and the third semester are still sold separately, requiring additional spending.
Expands the Thieves Den with a museum, minigames, and a gallery that encourages completionists.The Thieves Den's trophy system requires grinding for specific in-game achievements, which can feel tedious.
Refines combat with technical damage and new enemy weaknesses, adding strategic depth.Technical damage calculations are not fully explained in-game, requiring external guides to master.
Offers multiple platform options including PC, Switch, and Xbox, broadening accessibility.Original Persona 5 save files cannot be transferred to Royal, forcing a full restart for returning players.
Adds a new true ending that ties all character arcs together, providing a more satisfying conclusion.The true ending requires specific confidant ranks, and missing them locks players into the original ending.
Improves the visual presentation with dynamic lighting and enhanced character models.On base PS4, Royal runs at 30 FPS, which can feel sluggish compared to the 60 FPS PC version.

Similarities Between Persona 5 and Royal

Shared AspectHow Persona 5 and Royal Are Alike
Core NarrativeBoth Persona 5 and Royal follow the same Phantom Thieves story, targeting corrupt adults in modern Tokyo.
Protagonist RoleIn both versions, you control the silent protagonist Joker, a transfer student accused of a crime.
Confidant SystemPersona 5 and Royal share the identical Confidant mechanic, where social links grant combat and utility perks.
Palace ExplorationBoth games feature handcrafted dungeons called Palaces, each with unique themes, puzzles, and treasure routes.
Mementos DepthsThe procedurally generated Mementos subway dungeon exists in both Persona 5 and Royal for grinding and requests.
Turn-Based CombatPersona 5 and Royal use identical turn-based battles, exploiting enemy weaknesses to trigger All-Out Attacks.
Persona FusionBoth titles feature the Velvet Room's fusion system, letting you combine personas to create stronger allies.
Social StatsKnowledge, Guts, Charm, Kindness, and Proficiency are the same five social stats in both Persona 5 and Royal.
Calendar SystemBoth games use a day-by-day calendar, forcing you to manage time between school, socializing, and dungeon crawling.
Phantom Thief OutfitsEach party member wears the same stylish Phantom Thief costume in both Persona 5 and Royal.
Main CastRyuji, Ann, Morgana, Yusuke, Makoto, Futaba, and Haru are all core party members in Persona 5 and Royal.
Antagonist GroupThe main villains—Kamoshida, Madarame, Kaneshiro, and Shido—are identical across Persona 5 and Royal.
All-Out AttackAfter hitting all enemies' weaknesses, both Persona 5 and Royal trigger the stylish cinematic All-Out Attack.
Baton PassThe Baton Pass mechanic, granting bonus damage after a critical hit, works the same in Persona 5 and Royal.
Gun AttacksEvery character uses a limited-ammo gun in both titles, useful for hitting physical weaknesses or knocking down.
Negotiation SystemDuring battle, you can talk to shadows in both Persona 5 and Royal to recruit them as personas or get items.
Fusion SpellsSpecial combo attacks between specific party members exist identically in Persona 5 and Royal.
DLC CostumesBoth Persona 5 and Royal support the same downloadable costume packs, including the iconic Catherine and P4D sets.
Difficulty OptionsSafety, Easy, Normal, Hard, and Challenge difficulty levels are available in both Persona 5 and Royal.
New Game PlusBoth versions carry over social stats, personas, and money into New Game Plus, enabling a faster second playthrough.
True Ending PathTo achieve the true ending, both Persona 5 and Royal require you to reject the final false reality offer.
Phantom Thief Calling CardSending a calling card before the final Palace boss is a mandatory step in both Persona 5 and Royal.
Morgana's RoleMorgana acts as the navigator, party member, and tutorial guide in both Persona 5 and Royal.
Futaba's NavigationFutaba provides the same support abilities, like position hacking and healing, in both Persona 5 and Royal.
Velvet Room AttendantsCaroline and Justine, the twin wardens, manage fusion and executions identically in Persona 5 and Royal.
Thieves GuildThe online Thieves Guild feature, letting you see other players' actions, is present in both Persona 5 and Royal.
Daily Life ActivitiesWorking part-time jobs, studying at the library, and visiting the bathhouse are shared activities in both games.
Treasure DemonsRare golden enemies, like the Crystal Skull, appear in both Persona 5 and Royal for bonus XP and fusion material.
Weather EffectsRainy days alter enemy spawn rates and some social activities in both Persona 5 and Royal.
Replay ValueBoth Persona 5 and Royal offer 80+ hour campaigns with multiple endings, encouraging multiple playthroughs.

Persona 5 or Royal: Which Should You Choose?

Choose Persona 5 Royal for the definitive experience, as it adds 20+ hours of story, a third semester, and quality-of-life combat upgrades. The deciding variable is your budget and time: Royal costs $20 more but offers nearly double the content. If you want the complete, enhanced narrative, Royal wins outright.

When to Use Persona 5

Choose Persona 5 when you are on a strict budget, as the original is often $10–$15 cheaper. It is also ideal for purists who want the original 2016 pacing without the added Kasumi storyline. If you plan to play only 60–80 hours and skip the extra semester, the base version still delivers a complete, satisfying arc.

When to Use Royal

Choose Royal when you want the maximum playtime, roughly 100–120 hours, and improved mechanics like Baton Pass and grappling hooks. It is the better pick for newcomers, as the added confidants and new ending provide a richer emotional payoff. If you value enhanced visuals, a new dungeon, and a more forgiving difficulty curve, Royal is the superior investment.

Common Misconceptions About Persona 5 and Royal

Common MythThe Reality
"Royal is just a re-release with better graphics."Persona 5 Royal adds a third semester, two new party members, and a new palace, making it a 30-hour content expansion.
"You can transfer your Persona 5 save to Royal."Royal does not accept Persona 5 save files; you must start fresh, though Royal's base game is identical for the first 60 hours.
"Royal's new content only appears after the original ending."Royal's new features, like the grappling hook and Showtime attacks, are available from the first palace, not just post-game.
"Kasumi is a full party member from the start."Kasumi Yoshizawa joins as a temporary ally in the third palace, becomes a permanent member in the sixth, and unlocks her third tier only in the third semester.
"The third semester is accessible without any new requirements."You must max the new Councillor confidant (Maruki) to rank 9 before November 18, or Royal's third semester is permanently locked.
"Royal's final boss is the same as the original game."Royal replaces the original final boss with a new antagonist, Dr. Maruki, and adds a separate true ending that requires specific dialogue choices.
"All DLC from Persona 5 is included free in Royal."Royal includes the original DLC costumes and personas for free, but the new Royal-exclusive DLC (like Kasumi's swimsuit) requires separate purchase.
"Royal's difficulty is identical to Persona 5."Royal adds a new 'Challenge' difficulty and rebalances boss fights, making them harder, but also introduces the overpowered 'Myriad Truths' persona.
"The original Persona 5 is now obsolete after Royal."Persona 5 remains the only version on PS3 and is shorter; Royal is PS4/PS5-only, so platform availability still matters for some players.
"Royal's new characters replace the original cast."Royal adds Kasumi, Maruki, and Akechi's new arc, but the original Phantom Thieves remain central with expanded social events and dialogue.
"The grappling hook is just a cosmetic addition."Royal's grappling hook lets you reach hidden treasure chests and new Will Seeds, which restore SP and grant unique accessories in each palace.
"Royal's palaces are completely redesigned layouts."Royal keeps the original palace layouts but adds new puzzle mechanics, optional stealth sections, and a few new rooms, not full redesigns.
"You can max all confidants in one playthrough of Royal."Royal gives you extra time in the third semester, but maxing all 22 confidants still requires a strict day-by-day guide; it's not automatic.
"Royal's true ending requires no extra steps beyond the third semester."To get Royal's true ending, you must also max Akechi to rank 8 and refuse Maruki's final offer during the last dialogue sequence.
"The new 'Showtime' attacks replace All-Out Attacks."Showtime attacks are optional pair-based finishers that trigger randomly, while All-Out Attacks remain a separate mechanic for downed enemies.
"Royal's new music is just remixes of the original soundtrack."Royal adds 20 new tracks, including 'Take Over' for normal battles and a new vocal theme for the third semester, not just remixes.
"The Thieves Den is a multiplayer mode."The Thieves Den is a single-player gallery where you view trophies, listen to music, and watch cutscenes; it has no online multiplayer features.
"Royal's new 'Will Seeds' are only found in the third semester."Will Seeds exist in all six original palaces in Royal, with three per palace, and they grant unique accessories and restore SP when collected.
"The original Persona 5's ending is canon, not Royal's."Atlus confirms Royal's true ending is the canonical continuation, as it sets up the sequel 'Persona 5 Strikers' and future spin-offs.
"Royal's new difficulty mode is only for New Game Plus."Challenge difficulty is available from the start of a fresh file, but it locks you out of using the 'Myriad Truths' persona until NG+.
"You can date Kasumi in the original game's time frame."Kasumi's romance is locked until the third semester; you cannot initiate her confidant romance before January, unlike other party members.
"Royal's technical performance is identical on PS4 and PS5."Royal runs at 60fps on PS5 via backward compatibility, while PS4 runs at 30fps with occasional frame drops in crowded areas.
"The new 'Batting Cage' and 'Darts' minigames are purely optional."Darts and billiards are required to unlock party members' third-tier personas, which are essential for the third semester's final boss.
"Royal removes all the controversial content from the original."Royal keeps the same M-rated themes, including the gay-panic scene and the adults-stalking-teens moments; no content was removed or censored.
"The original Persona 5's platinum trophy is easier to get."Royal's platinum trophy is harder because it requires reading all books, completing all requests, and maxing all confidants, including the new ones.
"Royal's new ending is a direct sequel hook for Strikers."Royal's true ending is self-contained and does not set up Strikers; Strikers continues from the original Persona 5's ending, not Royal's.
"You can skip the original Persona 5 and play Royal directly."Royal is a standalone expansion, but you'll miss the original's pacing and the emotional weight of Akechi's arc, which Royal assumes you know.
"Royal's new 'Third Semester' is just a bonus dungeon."The third semester is a full 10-15 hour story arc with a new palace, new social events, and a new final boss, not a simple post-game dungeon.
"All Royal-exclusive features are locked behind the third semester."Only the third semester and Kasumi's romance are locked; the grappling hook, Will Seeds, Showtime attacks, and new personas are available from the start.

Conclusion

Difference Between Persona 5 and Royal comes down to content depth versus time commitment. Royal adds a third semester, two new characters, and refined gameplay mechanics, making it the definitive version. Choose Persona 5 for a shorter, original experience; choose Royal for the fullest, most polished story.

FAQs on Difference Between Persona 5 and Royal

What is the main difference between Persona 5 and Persona 5 Royal?
Persona 5 Royal is an expanded re-release of Persona 5 that adds a third semester, two new characters, a new social link, and a redesigned palace, offering roughly 20-30 additional hours of gameplay.
Which game is better for a new player, Persona 5 or Persona 5 Royal?
Persona 5 Royal is the better choice for new players because it includes quality-of-life improvements like unlimited gun ammo, new battle mechanics, and a more forgiving difficulty curve, making the original feel obsolete.
Is Persona 5 Royal just a DLC or a full standalone game?
Persona 5 Royal is a full standalone game, not a DLC, and it requires no ownership of the original Persona 5, containing all original content plus new story arcs, characters, and activities.
What is the cost difference between Persona 5 and Persona 5 Royal?
Persona 5 Royal typically costs $59.99 at launch, while Persona 5 is usually $49.99, but Royal frequently goes on sale for $30 or less, making it the better value for the extra content.
Are there any risks of playing Persona 5 Royal before the original Persona 5?
There are no significant risks because Royal is a definitive edition that includes the entire original story, so you will not miss any essential plot points by skipping the original release.
Is Persona 5 Royal compatible with all PlayStation and Nintendo consoles?
Persona 5 Royal is compatible with PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Nintendo Switch, and PC via Steam, but the original Persona 5 is only available on PlayStation 3 and PlayStation 4.
What is the biggest mistake beginners make when starting Persona 5 Royal?
The biggest mistake beginners make is ignoring the new "Showtime" attacks and the grappling hook mechanic, which are exclusive to Royal and can turn tough battles into easy victories.
Can I transfer my save data from Persona 5 to Persona 5 Royal?
No, you cannot transfer save data from Persona 5 to Persona 5 Royal because Royal has a different story structure and new mechanics, so you must start a fresh playthrough.
Which game offers the better real-world use case for a time-limited player?
Persona 5 Royal is the better real-world use case for a time-limited player because its new "Thieves Den" and fast-forward dialogue options let you complete the main story in about 80 hours versus 100 hours in the original.
Can I switch from Persona 5 to Persona 5 Royal mid-playthrough without losing progress?
No, you cannot switch mid-playthrough because Royal is a separate game, so you would lose all progress and need to restart from the beginning to experience the new content.